Insurance Claim Reality Series | Article 1 of 8
Estimated reading time: 4 minutes
After property damage, policyholders are often overwhelmed, under-informed, and under-prepared for the complexity of an insurance claim. In that vulnerable moment, many ask the same question:
“Isn’t there someone who can help me with this — preferably for free?”
It’s an understandable impulse. A loss is disruptive, expensive, and rarely budgeted. But the idea of a “free” representative in the insurance claim process is common. It is also one of the most costly misunderstandings policyholders face.
This article explains what a public insurance adjuster does, when hiring one makes sense, and why entering that relationship without an intention to honor the contract can create serious problems for everyone involved.
What Is a Public Insurance Adjuster?
A public insurance adjuster (PA) is a state-licensed professional who represents policyholders, not insurance companies, in the preparation, presentation, and negotiation of property insurance claims.
Unlike:
- Company adjusters, who work for the insurance carrier, or
- Independent adjusters, who are hired by insurers on a contract basis,
a public adjuster works exclusively for the insured.
Their responsibilities often include:
- Interpreting policy language and coverage
- Inspecting and documenting damage
- Preparing detailed estimates and inventories
- Communicating and negotiating with the insurance carrier
- Helping guide the claim through settlement, appraisal, or resolution
A public adjuster’s role is advocacy, not repair, not legal advice, and not sales.
Why Policyholders Look for “Free” Help After a Loss
In nearly every major loss we handle, we encounter policyholders who say some version of:
“I didn’t plan for this, and I don’t have money set aside to hire help.”
That reality is especially common after:
- Fires
- Large water losses
- Lightning strikes
- Commercial or condo claims
- Losses that displace families or interrupt business operations
Insurance premiums are paid year after year. Many policyholders assume that claim assistance should be “included.” They believe that someone else, such as a contractor, a mitigation company, or even a friend, can negotiate with the insurer at no cost.
The problem is this:
Professional claim advocacy is skilled labor, regulated by law, and never truly free.
When representation is advertised as “free,” the cost is often:
- Hidden in inflated repair contracts
- Shifted to vendors with conflicts of interest
- Or paid indirectly through reduced claim outcomes
The Risk of Hiring a Public Adjuster Without Intending to Honor the Contract
Public adjusters work under written, regulated contracts approved by state insurance departments. These agreements outline:
- The scope of services
- The fee structure
- The policyholder’s obligations
- The adjuster’s ethical and legal duties
Unfortunately, we sometimes encounter situations where a policyholder:
- Hires a PA hoping the claim will “settle quickly”
- Assumes the fee can be renegotiated after the work is done
- Or plans to terminate representation once progress is made
This creates serious risks for everyone involved.
For the Policyholder
- Potential breach of contract
- Disrupted claim continuity
- Loss of credibility with the insurance carrier
- Delayed or reduced settlement
For the Public Adjuster
- Unpaid professional labor
- Ethical conflicts
- Licensing and compliance exposure
A public adjuster is not a contingency shortcut or a temporary tool. If you hire one, it should be with the same good-faith intent you would bring to hiring any licensed professional.
When Hiring a Public Insurance Adjuster Makes Sense
Hiring a PA is often appropriate when:
- The loss is complex or high-value
- The insurer’s estimate seems incomplete or understated
- Damage is disputed or denied
- You lack the time, expertise, or emotional bandwidth to manage the claim
- The claim is heading toward appraisal or prolonged negotiation
In these situations, professional representation can protect policy benefits. It can also prevent costly mistakes. This is true only when both parties enter the relationship transparently and in good faith.
A Better Way to Think About Claim Advocacy
Instead of asking, “Who can help me for free?”
A better question is:
“What professional help will protect the benefits I’ve already paid for?”
Insurance claims are not customer service transactions — they are contractual negotiations. Public adjusters provide specialized services. Like accountants, engineers, or attorneys, these services carry value because they are regulated. They are also skilled and accountable.
What’s Coming Next in This Series
This article is Part 1 of an 8-part series. It is designed to help policyholders understand how insurance claims really work. It explains more than just how they’re marketed.
In upcoming articles, we’ll cover:
- Why initial insurance checks are often incomplete
- Hidden deadlines that can jeopardize coverage
- What “full and final settlement” really means
- Why undisputed payments don’t close claims
- And common mistakes made early in the recovery process
Disclaimer
Green Public Insurance Adjusting and its staff members are not attorneys and do not provide legal advice. This article is for general educational purposes only. Policyholders should consult qualified legal counsel for legal questions related to insurance claims or contracts.
Related Links:
